Use ICSI with IVF Treatment – Benefits, Costs, and FAQs

What is ICSI?

ICSI (intracytoplasmic sperm injection) is a simple process on the surface. Embryologists performing ICSI use a small, glass tool called a pipette to inject a single sperm into a single egg. Fertility doctors recommend and use ICSI when the risk of IVF failure is high due to issues with sperm quantity or quality, egg quantity or quality, or a combination of factors.

ICSI and IVF

Successful IVF treatment requires two important events: fertilization and implantation. Fertilization usually occurs several hours after a sperm penetrates an egg. Under normal IVF circumstances, fertility specialists mix sperm with an egg in a dish, and allow time for fertilization to occur. Unfortunately, in a small amount of IVF cases, fertilization does not occur.

Injecting sperm directly into the egg increases the chances of fertilization where it would otherwise be extremely difficult or impossible.

Male Infertility Factor

Male infertility contributes to about 20% of all infertility cases (approximately 1 in 5 infertile couples). In male infertility factor cases, sperm cannot or do not successfully fertilize eggs, due to one or more issues.

Low sperm count makes up the majority of male infertility factor cases. Sometimes, the testes simply do not produce enough sperm for pregnancy. Other times, blockages and other transport issues (including vasectomy) make pregnancy difficult or impossible.

IVF normally requires large numbers of motile, healthy sperm. The sperm collected in the IVF process must be able to reach the egg and permeate the egg’s membrane in a certain amount of time. If the male’s sperm count is too low, the chances of IVF success drop dramatically. Similarly, low sperm motility significantly reduces chances of fertilization.

ICSI improves chances of success by removing the barriers to fertilization caused by male infertility. With this process, fertility specialists require fewer sperm, and can around issues of low sperm motility.

Diagnosing Male Infertility

After an IVF consultation or as part of the fertility diagnosis, fertility doctors test the male partner’s sperm for male infertility factor. Male infertility factor is usually diagnosed after analyzing semen a number of times, not just once. The tests look for issues with motility (movement) as well as abnormal appearance of sperm or low numbers of sperm. Doctors generally also complete a physical exam before diagnosing male infertility.

There are several different treatments for male infertility. Ultimately, the treatment depends on the cause, which varies from genetic disorders to actual, physical blockages in the testes or penis. If a hormone imbalance caused male infertility, fertility doctors may treat it with prescriptions. Fertility doctors may also suggest surgery, if the issue involves a blockage.

If those treatments do not address the cause, fertility doctors may suggest ICSI with IVF as a fertility treatment.

ICSI Benefits

ICSI increases the chance of success with IVF in specific couples and situations. As discussed above, it makes pregnancy possible in situations where male fertility prevents it, including:

  • Low sperm count
  • Low sperm motility
  • Blockages/sperm transport issues
  • Multiple failed IVF cycles
  • Low egg count or poor egg quality

Furthermore, the benefits go beyond male infertility factor and egg quantity or quality issues. Men who’ve had a vasectomy generally cannot produce offspring unless it’s reversed. With ISCI, however, fertility specialists can use the male’s sperm (which are still being produced) to fertilize the eggs. Other situations include paralysis or a physical defect that impacts sex, ejaculation, sperm production, or another male reproduction issue.

Egg Quality Issues. Directly injecting sperm can also improve IVF success in cases with a low number of viable, healthy eggs, or poor egg quality. Sometimes referred to as “egg factor,” these issues lower the chances of success with IVF. When fertility doctors use ICSI with IVF, sometimes, the risks that egg factors pose can be mitigated or eliminated.

What is the process?

ICSI differs from IVF in one primary way. With IVF, fertility doctors mix many sperm together in a dish with a viable, healthy egg. Typically, a healthy sperm then permeates the lining of the egg and fertilizes it.

But with direct sperm injection, the fertilization process is more straightforward. Embryologists “help” sperm fertilize the eggs by placing them directly inside the egg.

  1. First, the fertility clinic collects sperm and retrieves eggs on the same day. Or, the clinic thaws frozen eggs, sperm, or both.
  2. After sperm collection and egg retrieval, an embryologist selects a sperm, and then injects that sperm directly into the egg, using a glass pipette (similar to a hollow needle). Ideally, the sperm and egg together become an embryo.
  3. The embryologist repeats the process for every egg.

Even if the male partner in a couple produces a small number of sperm, embryologists can successfully perform ICSI.

In most IVF cases, fertilization happens 60 to 70% of the time. This process improves chances of fertilization, but does not guarantee fertilization. After fertilization, the eggs must divide into four to eight cells and become embryos before they can be transferred back into the uterus. That process takes approximately 3 days, but can take as few as two days.

When couples choose ICSI, the embryologist performs the work the same day the sperm and egg are retrieved. Similarly to IVF, couples can choose to use donor sperm or their own, or donor eggs or their own.

If the sperm count in the ejaculate is too low or is non-existent, a specialty clinic can extract sperm using a process called Testicular Sperm Extraction (TESE).

Success Rates

As explained earlier, normal fertilization rates with IVF are 60 to 70%. This process does increase this rate to 70 to 85%. As with IVF, success rates vary by clinic. Each clinic has its own set of success rates you should research before choosing the clinic.

Fertilization rate, pregnancy rate, and live birth rate mean different things. Be sure to understand the clinic’s live birth rate, too, if you want to have a clear idea of the overall success rate. The fertilization rate applies only to the number of eggs fertilized with ICSI.

Pregnancy rate applies only to the number of pregnancies per transfer – the number may mislead you because it includes miscarriages and stillbirths. Live birth rate, however, applies to the number of live, healthy births per transfer. Usually, fertility clinics consider live birth rate as the true measure of success.

Risks and Side Effects

The process poses some serious risks that could impact pregnancy or the baby. For example, if an unhealthy sperm fertilizes the egg, the baby is at risk for abnormalities.

Risk of Multiples – Lower than without ICSI

While IVF generally increases risk of multiples, ICSI reduces the chances of having multiple births. In fact, research shows that directly injecting sperm into eggs resulted in more singleton births than multiples. With this process, a single sperm fertilizes a single egg, and generally, the single embryo is transferred. There is a small risk of the embryo dividing and resulting in identical twins. Without it, multiple eggs may be fertilized.

Note, however, that with or without ICSI, if multiple embryos are transferred, a woman could become pregnant with multiple babies.

If a woman does become pregnant with multiples, risks include:

  • Premature delivery
  • Low birth rate
  • Difficult pregnancy
  • Higher blood pressure
  • Gestational diabetes

Risks to Embryos

The process of injecting sperm using a needle, through the lining of the egg creates some risk of damage to embryos. Unfortunately, some eggs become damaged, but “approximately 90% of the eggs injected survive” (Source). Most likely, an embryologist will fertilize multiple eggs with sperm and therefore increase the chances of having a viable embryo to transfer.

Risks of Birth Defects

According to Attain Fertility, the risk of having a baby with birth defects after using ICSI is minimal, at less than one percent. The potential birth defects include:

  • Chromosome abnormalities
  • Hypospadias
  • Angelman syndrome
  • Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome
  • Physical disabilities (especially around male genitals)

Why does ICSI pose a risk of birth defects? The primary reason is that ICSI as a process boosts the chances of fertilizing the egg, but does not necessarily require healthy sperm to do so. It simply improves fertilization and does not rule out the possibility of birth defects.

With natural fertilization, the healthiest sperm tend to fertilize the eggs, while unhealthy, slow sperm do not. In other words, natural fertilization allows for the natural selection process to do its work of ensuring only the strongest and best sperm produce offspring.

ICSI ultimately removes the natural selection process and in doing so, creates risk. It increases the chance of birth defects by giving potentially unhealthy sperm a chance to fertilize the egg. The risks most commonly associated with ICSI include physical abnormalities or disabilities. An article published on UKHealthCentre.org suggests the risk could be as high as 4.2% of births from ICSI resulting in a major disability.

Before choosing ICSI, discuss the risks with a fertility specialists. Always ask about potential risks and side effects, given your specific infertility situation, rather than general risks.

How much does ICSI cost?

Costs vary by fertility clinic and location. On average, the process costs around $1,500. You can use an IVF calculator to determine the cost of IVF with and without ICSI. This is an additional, separate cost and may not be covered by insurance.

References

  1. Embryo transfer and multiple births (http://www.hfea.gov.uk/2587.html#3047)
  2. Advantages ICSI Disadvantages of ICSI (http://www.healthcentre.org.uk/fertility-treatment/icsi.html)
  3. Stages of the IVF Process | ICSI Procedure | The Bridge Centre (http://www.thebridgecentre.co.uk/fertility_treatments/IVF_ICSI_treatment_stages)
  4. Male Infertility – Symptoms, Causes, Diagnosis, Treatment (https://www.andrologyaustralia.org/your-health/male-infertility/)
  5. Male Infertility – Mayo Clinic (http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/male-infertility/basics/tests-diagnosis/con-20033113)
  6. ICSI-IVF: Risks, What to Expect, and Success Rates (https://www.verywell.com/what-you-should-know-about-icsi-ivf-1960209)